552: Will Storr | Understanding Social Position and the Status Game

Cancel Culture

Cancel culture is deeply rooted in human behavior, reflecting ancient tribal justice dynamics. Will Storr explains that cancel culture mirrors the way tribes historically dealt with transgressors through gossip and consensus, often leading to severe punishment without a formal leader 1. This behavior is hardwired into our cognition, making it challenging to stop, but Storr suggests that new social norms and legislation could mitigate its impact 2.

Cancel culture is part of our basic cognition. It's what we do. So it's going to be very hard to stop.

--- Will Storr

The evolution of cancel culture highlights the need for societal change to address its pervasive nature.

   

Victimhood & Status

Victimhood can paradoxically elevate one's status within a group, as Will Storr notes, by garnering attention and support from peers 3. This dynamic is often exploited through exaggerated or fabricated events to gain moral superiority. Storytelling plays a crucial role in this process, as narratives that simplify complex realities can reinforce group identity and status hierarchies 4.

When you understand morality as a status game, all of that stuff makes sense.

--- Will Storr

Recognizing these patterns can help individuals navigate the social landscape more effectively.