1010: Participation Trophies | Skeptical Sunday

Origins

Participation trophies have a surprisingly long history, dating back to the early 20th century. Jason Feifer explains that these trophies emerged as a way to balance the love of sports with the exhaustion and societal changes post-World War I. The University of Minnesota even created a 30-inch sterling silver participation trophy in 1924, highlighting the widespread acceptance of these awards at the time 1. Feifer notes, "Participation trophies are just everywhere, rewarding children for just playing" 2.

   

Impact

The impact of participation trophies on children has been a topic of debate. Jason Feifer consulted Dr. Ken Barish, a clinical professor of psychology, who believes that rewarding young children for participation is beneficial. Barish argues, "When a kid is really young, we should reward them for participating... And then they get older, and they learn the concepts of winning and losing" 3. This perspective challenges the notion that participation trophies create a generation of entitled individuals.

   

Perception

Public perception of participation trophies has shifted over time. Initially seen as positive, they are now often criticized. Jason Feifer points out that critics like Steve Harvey mistakenly believe these trophies are a recent phenomenon. Feifer states, "Their entire argument hinges upon this belief that the participation trophy is new" 4. This misconception fuels the ongoing debate about their impact on youth.