62: How to Get over Your Significant Other’s Colorful Dating History | Feedback Friday

Ethical Concerns

The ethics of speculative work in design are hotly debated, with Jason DeFillippo highlighting the challenges faced by designers on crowdsourcing platforms. He argues that while these platforms offer opportunities to build portfolios, they often exploit designers by having them work for free without guarantees of payment 1. Many designers' works are stolen due to the lack of contracts, leading to unethical practices 1. Jordan Harbinger acknowledges the issue of design theft, noting that some designers automate their processes to mitigate the risk of being ripped off 2.

If you're stealing, you're a jerk.

--- Jordan Harbinger

Despite these challenges, finding a reliable designer on such platforms can lead to long-term collaborations 2.

   

Industry Impact

The debate over crowdsourced design platforms centers on their impact on the industry and the value of creative work. Jordan Harbinger compares these platforms to auditions, where designers showcase their skills for potential clients 3. He believes that these platforms provide opportunities for new designers to gain clients without extensive marketing efforts 4. However, critics argue that such platforms exploit designers by undervaluing their time and effort, likening it to gambling rather than a fair business transaction 3.

It's having people audition for a job just like any actor, a singer, a performer.

--- Jordan Harbinger

While Harbinger acknowledges the increased competition, he remains unconvinced that it makes it impossible for good designers to earn a living 4.